YouSaid · the spoken record

Wei

lines on the record
22
first
2024-09-17
most recent
2024-09-17
sittings or episodes
1
sources
podcast

Every line below is reproduced as it was said and linked to the record it came from. Nothing here is summarised or generated. Directory · Search · Corrections

  1. “A specific product, prices can go down, and Chinese manufacturing activity can put downward pressure on these products. And I think for global investors, if we see another trade war and then global investors want to rethink where to allocate their capital, then we can see global portfolio investment flows moving away from China into other countries. So you can see there are several themes going out here and depend on what is dominating faster driving China growth slowdown. The impact will be different and the impact on different countries will be quite different as well.”

    2024-09-17 · Goldman Sachs Exchanges · Why China’s economy is struggling · IDENTIFIED FROM THE TRANSCRIPT

  2. “I will also say that even in the scenario of a trade war where it's girl-to-girl slowing and grow away inflation picking up, the heterogeneity across countries might be interesting because you think about the global supply chain reallocation is the second trade war is generating accelerated supply chain rearrangement, then you can see some countries benefiting more versus other countries as multinational companies moving to other countries outside of China or Chinese manufacturing want to strategically position themselves in other countries to avoid the US tariffs. And on the price side as well, I think you might expect that some Chinese products facing US tariff will have to find a market elsewhere. So for those type of products, even though the overall global inflation may pick up for these”

    2024-09-17 · Goldman Sachs Exchanges · Why China’s economy is struggling · IDENTIFIED FROM THE TRANSCRIPT

  3. “It was really the slowdown driven by housing and consumption, then the impact on the rest of the world would be pretty straightforward, negative for iron ore imports by China from Australia and Brazil, and less purchases of luxury goods from European countries by Chinese consumers. That linkage is relatively straightforward. If the trade war is at the center of why Chinese economy is slowing, then by our global economists' estimates, global growth will slow.”

    2024-09-17 · Goldman Sachs Exchanges · Why China’s economy is struggling · IDENTIFIED FROM THE TRANSCRIPT

  4. “So, if the Chinese economy does slow, as we expect it to, but obviously we've talked about some downside risks as well, what are the implications for the global economy at this point? Obviously, it's the second largest economy in the world. So how much will that impact growth around the world?”

    2024-09-17 · Goldman Sachs Exchanges · Why China’s economy is struggling · IDENTIFIED FROM THE TRANSCRIPT

  5. “I think a lot of the policy constraints today are self imposed. You know, the government may say that looking at government debt-to-GDP ratio, combining both central and local, implicit and explicit is already over 100% of GDP. But I don't see why that can't be 110 or 120% GDP. So from that point of view, they have quite a bit of a space to lever up the central government and conduct the fiscal easy.”

    2024-09-17 · Goldman Sachs Exchanges · Why China’s economy is struggling · IDENTIFIED FROM THE TRANSCRIPT

  6. “Yes, I think in that scenario trade tensions ratch up significantly and gross impact as big as the 2018-19 experience, then that would translate into job losses. And at that point, I think the Chinese government will not be hesitating anymore and will introduce large fiscal stimulus combined with further monetary policy easy to cushion that blow from tariff increases.”

    2024-09-17 · Goldman Sachs Exchanges · Why China’s economy is struggling · IDENTIFIED FROM THE TRANSCRIPT

  7. “That seems huge to me, Wei. And so if that happens, wouldn't that be a catalyst for the government to react much more aggressively with fiscal stimulus, with other stimulus, to try to counteract this type of big hit to the economy?”

    2024-09-17 · Goldman Sachs Exchanges · Why China’s economy is struggling · IDENTIFIED FROM THE TRANSCRIPT

  8. “So, those are the few things we learned from the 2018-2019 experience. If I were to do a linear extrapolation, which probably won't be correct, but it's a starting point to think about what would a 60% tariff on China do to Chinese growth and Chinese currency, we estimated that the growth impact might be two percentage points and then the R&B may depreciate to above eight in terms of USDC and Y.”

    2024-09-17 · Goldman Sachs Exchanges · Why China’s economy is struggling · IDENTIFIED FROM THE TRANSCRIPT

  9. “So, end of the day, Chinese paid surpluses may not decline as much. We saw in 2018-19 Chinese growth took a hit. It wasn't really due to the trade channel alone. A lot of the growth shock came from the uncertainty channel. What that means is that you look at a company's CapEx, they were declining for companies with exposure to the US and companies without exposure to the US. It's the environment when you're in the middle of a trade war, not sure how much longer it's going to last or what's the final equilibrium we're going to reach, then all companies are going to cut back on CapEx, and that's going to impact the growth more generally than the U.S. tariffs on Chinese exporters alone. And we also saw that Chinese currency, the R&B, depreciated notably against the dollar.”

    2024-09-17 · Goldman Sachs Exchanges · Why China’s economy is struggling · IDENTIFIED FROM THE TRANSCRIPT

  10. “You're right, we don't have a template. All we can do is look at the 2018-19, the US-China Trade War Experience, and try to draw some lessons. Back in the 2018-19 U.S.-China Trade War, the United States imposed up to 25% tariff on over $300 billion of Chinese goods imported from China to the US. If we use the 2018-19 experience, we can learn a few things. One is that Chinese exports to the US did decline after US put tariffs on China. But if you look at the overall China's trade surplus with all trading partners, right now China's trade surplus is the highest ever. So in a sense, bilateral trade will be impacted significantly by tariffs, but global trade will be rerouted and redirected.”

    2024-09-17 · Goldman Sachs Exchanges · Why China’s economy is struggling · IDENTIFIED FROM THE TRANSCRIPT

  11. “And then, of course, if we think about really the glaring threat to Chinese exports, the risk of tariffs following the outcome of the U.S. election, of course, no one knows what's going to happen with the election, and really no one knows what's going to happen with tariffs even once the election outcome is determined. But how might tariffs impact the outlook for Chinese exports and growth overall?”

    2024-09-17 · Goldman Sachs Exchanges · Why China’s economy is struggling · IDENTIFIED FROM THE TRANSCRIPT

  12. “In the near term, I think Chinese exports can continue to grow and surprise us to the upside. Why is that? Because they're so competitive in terms of quality, in terms of cost. You ask any purchasing manager regardless of their political views and how they think of a Chinese exports or Chinese overcapacity issue. If they were faced with the same products about 30% cheaper, it's very hard to say no. We're not forecasting global recession, global growth is going to slow, but still quite resilient. In this environment, in the near term, we think Chinese exports can continue to be strong. But over the medium, long term, if you look at the history of a global imbalance, right, Chinese trade surplus has been as high as ever, we think that”

    2024-09-17 · Goldman Sachs Exchanges · Why China’s economy is struggling · IDENTIFIED FROM THE TRANSCRIPT

  13. “So it sounds like that is going to hang over the economy for a while. But if we talk about the right spot, you mentioned, of course, exports have been much stronger than expected. But if I look around the world, growth is slowing globally. So how much risk is there to that export strength that is really booing the economy and maybe one of the only bright spots in the economy right now?”

    2024-09-17 · Goldman Sachs Exchanges · Why China’s economy is struggling · IDENTIFIED FROM THE TRANSCRIPT

  14. “loop on the real economy will likely take a few more years to play out. But we're basically dealing with an oversupplied physical asset. So even though, as you mentioned, the Chinese government has taken measures to address it, how much more can they really do to address this problem? I think they can do more. What is holding them bad? I think there are a couple of things. One is the mentality and the history, because in previous cycles, whenever they ease the property market, prices start to increase, especially in the top tier cities. So I see a little bit of dynamic here. They worry if they eat too much, then all the effort”

    2024-09-17 · Goldman Sachs Exchanges · Why China’s economy is struggling · IDENTIFIED FROM THE TRANSCRIPT

  15. “If your star is down 70%, eventually the total under construction should also be down 70%. There's still some distance to go. In addition, we're seeing property prices have not really bottomed. Latest data continue to see declines sequentially in property prices. So if there's a transmission from house price decline to household balance sheet deterioration to negative sentiment toward consumption, then that has not completely played out yet until we see stabilization in house prices. Let alone the local government transmission mechanism where local governments don't have land sales revenue short of a cash, not really balancing expenditure versus revenue, and at the same time try to deliver from the debt accumulated in previous years. That negativity”

    2024-09-17 · Goldman Sachs Exchanges · Why China’s economy is struggling · IDENTIFIED FROM THE TRANSCRIPT

  16. “What's happening in the property sector probably accelerated the softening in construction. Got it. If we dig into these property sector woes that we've been talking about for years now, where are we in terms of that cycle? Are we close to bottoming at all at this point? From the peak of the market in 2021, we're three years in. Are we at the bottom depends on which indicator you're talking about? The more leading indicators such as land sales, housing stars, I think they are probably around the bottom after declining at least 70% from the peak. But if you look at the total under construction, the floor space under construction or the construction activity, we don't think we're at the bottom yet because that stock of a property under construction only declined around a 20%.”

    2024-09-17 · Goldman Sachs Exchanges · Why China’s economy is struggling · IDENTIFIED FROM THE TRANSCRIPT

  17. “Fewer jobs, lower income growth, more uncertainty about the future, all of which are negative for consumption. I think we're seeing that property sector decline, the weaker than expected property sector performance really weighing on income, on wages and all consumer sentiment. And on top of that, I think a lot of the government policies, which were designed for other purposes, are inadvertently impacting consumption negatively. For example, the crackdown in the financial sector, a lot of the people working in the financial sector are being laid off or facing significant salary cuts, that is going to translate into weak sentiment and consumption cutdowns, which combined with”

    2024-09-17 · Goldman Sachs Exchanges · Why China’s economy is struggling · IDENTIFIED FROM THE TRANSCRIPT

  18. “Away from around 5% gross target, we're expecting 4.7% of gross this year. Okay, interesting. Do you think that that slowdown in the consumption side is really just the real estate sector trickling through or what do you attribute the weakness in the consumer to? I think the relationship between consumption and the housing market has a bit of ambiguity in there. In the longer term, if Chinese households no longer want to buy properties, they don't need to save a big down payment. If you give them the same income, they can consume more. It's good for the consumption sector if housing is weak and people don't want to buy the second, the third, the fourth apartment. But in the near term, a slowing property sector, a depressed housing market is going to translate into weak economy.”

    2024-09-17 · Goldman Sachs Exchanges · Why China’s economy is struggling · IDENTIFIED FROM THE TRANSCRIPT

  19. “Better than we thought. The latest data showing export volume up 15%, 1.5% year from a already pretty high level. If anything, the property numbers are even worse than we were expecting. We thought this year property sales starts will be down 10% compared to last year, but it's on track for 20% decline year. And what really made the difference is consumption. It was stable, but now we're seeing for a few months consumption is slowing. Retail sales in the month of August only increased 2% from a year ago levels. When you have the good exports and the bad property coupled with softening consumption, that's really driven our view that the growth is going to be some distance.”

    2024-09-17 · Goldman Sachs Exchanges · Why China’s economy is struggling · IDENTIFIED FROM THE TRANSCRIPT

  20. “Appeasing policies on the property sector destocking properties and trying to stabilize the largest part of the economy. And the combination of good data and policy easing measures got the market excited. At the time, we were characterizing it not too good, not too bad, but rather a stable picture and activity did slow down quite a bit from May to now we're talking in September. If I think about what has changed back in May, if you look at exports, they were pretty good. You look at a property pretty bad, but there were hopes of a policy easing generating a boost to the sector. And consumption was a holding up pretty well considering the housing bust we were in. But fast forward today, what has changed? If anything exports were even”

    2024-09-17 · Goldman Sachs Exchanges · Why China’s economy is struggling · IDENTIFIED FROM THE TRANSCRIPT

  21. “Chinese equities were taking off, so it was a very, in some ways, surprising, upbeat conversation relative to our prior expectations. But today it feels like a really different picture. Investor confidence seems to have waned. Obviously Chinese equities have substantially underperformed of late. And we've seen a slew of global banks downgrading their growth forecasts for the country. Bring us up to speed on how we got here and how the narrative has changed, at least in my mind, so dramatically from only a few months ago. So looking back in May earlier this year, at that time, we just got the first quarter real GDP growth of 5.3% young year, which it was above the government's goal of around 5% growth. And then around May, policymakers announced a set of”

    2024-09-17 · Goldman Sachs Exchanges · Why China’s economy is struggling · IDENTIFIED FROM THE TRANSCRIPT

  22. “Downgrades. That's the word that pops into my mind when it comes to economic growth in China these days, the world's second largest economy continues to struggle with a real estate downturn, slowing consumer spending, and geopolitical tensions. And that's raising doubts that the country can even meet its official growth target of around 5% this year. So a lot of economy watchers have recently downgraded their Chinese growth forecasts. That made me curious about where our China economist stands in all of this. So today I'm speaking with our chief China economist in Goldman Sachs Research, Huishan, who's joining me remotely from Hong Kong. Hui, welcome back to the program. Thanks for having me. So let's get into it. Hui, we've not sat down only May of this year, so only a handful of months ago. And when I think back to that conversation, the narrative went something like this. Chinese growth was much better than expected heading into 2024.”

    2024-09-17 · Goldman Sachs Exchanges · Why China’s economy is struggling · IDENTIFIED FROM THE TRANSCRIPT