YouSaid · the spoken record

Joel David Hamkins

We hold 128 passages that may be Joel David Hamkins’s. We do not publish them until we can confirm who spoke. See the correction.

On the record 2025

159
LINES ON RECORD
1
SITTING OR EPISODE
1
SOURCE
2025
ON RECORD

podcast

This is everything the corpus holds for Joel David Hamkins. It is not everything they have said on the record.

Every line below is reproduced as it was said and credited to the record it came from, and links to that record wherever it can be linked. Nothing here is summarised or generated. Directory · Search · Corrections

  1. “Okay, but unfortunately I don't really have to choose between them. So you ask about the most beautiful idea in philosophy. And I would have to say that I think it's the distinction between truth and proof, the one that we discussed already. It's so profound and gets at the heart of so many philosophical issues. I mean, of course, this is a distinction that's maybe born in mathematics or mathematical logic, but that's already philosophical to a degree. And it's fundamentally a philosophical distinction. The truth is about the”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  2. “Care to decide whether I'm a mathematician or philosopher and my work is engaging with mathematics and with philosophical issues in mathematics and with plain philosophy and this ample region between these two subjects so it's not necessary to choose. I remember when I first went to Oxford and I told my daughter that I was going to become professor of philosophy in Oxford and she looked at me plaintively and said but papa you're not a philosopher Because in her mind, you know, her father was the mathematician and her mother was the philosopher because my wife, Barbara, is a philosopher. Now, also at Notre Dame, we're together there.”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  3. “So I have a foot in both Fields Philosophy and Mathematics. Some contexts, I seem to be required to choose whether I'm a mathematician or a philosopher. I mean, my training is in mathematics, my PhD, all my degrees are mathematics, but somehow I turned myself into a philosopher over the years because my mathematical work was engaging with these philosophical issues. And so when I went in New York, I had appointments first in mathematics only, but then eventually I was also joining the philosophy faculty at the Graduate Center. And when I went to Oxford for the first time, my main appointment was in philosophy, and that's also true now at Notre Dame, although I'm also concurrent professor in mathematics. I have math PhD students still and philosophy PhD students. And so I don't really...”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  4. “Continuing with the construction of the V hierarchy and girdle. Zermelo's proof of the well order principle using the axiom of choice is a transfinite recursive construction. And so the idea of just counting past infinity is so simple and elegant and has led to so much fascinating mathematics.”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  5. “First number that comes after all, those numbers will be omega squared. And this one is the first compound limit ordinal because it's a limit ordinal is one of these numbers, an ordinal, that doesn't have an immediate predecessor like omega and omega times 2, omega times 3, those are all limit ordinals. But omega squared is the limit ordinal, but it's also a limit of limit ordinals because the omega times three, omega times four, and so on, those are all limit ordinals that limit up to omega squared. And then, of course, you form omega squared plus one, and then omega squared plus two, and so on. And it never stops. And it's just absolutely beautiful and amazing. And furthermore, forms the foundation for these transfinite recursive constructions that came later, I mean, starting with the canorbendixon theorem that I mentioned.”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  6. “The most beautiful idea in mathematics is the transfinite ordinals. These were the number system invented by Georg Kentor about counting beyond infinity, just the idea of counting beyond infinity. I mean, you count through the ordinary numbers, the natural numbers 0, 1, 2, 3, and so on, and then you're not done because after that comes omega and then omega plus 1 and omega plus 2 and so on. And you can always add one. And so of course, after you count through all those numbers of the form omega plus n, then you get to omega plus omega, the first number after all those. And then comes omega plus omega plus one and so on. You can always add one. And so you can just keep counting through the ordinals. It never ends. Eventually you get to omega times 3, omega times four, and so on. And then the limit of those numbers.”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  7. “Yes, and so I think that the chat programs and so on are producing these arguments that look really, they look like that's what they're striving to do. It's what they're designed to do. They're not designed to make a logically correct argument. They're designed to make something that looks like a logically correct argument. And it's easy to get fooled if you're not skeptical. And so that's why I worry a bit when people rely on AI for mathematical arguments. I mean, using tying them to lean in the formal proof verification systems and so on, this is a totally different way of operating. But for the sort of ordinary person sitting down and using chat.”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  8. “Except at the time, you know, I didn't know anything, I was an undergrad and LaTeX was sort of unheard of. And so I was producing these beautifully typeset, you know, problem set solutions and so on. And I would print it up and submit it and so on. And the grades would come back terrible grades. And I realized what was happening is that The copy was so beautiful mathematically typeset in this way. It looked like the kind of mathematics you find in a book, you know, because basically that's the only time you saw that kind of mathematical typesetting was in a In a professional published book. And those mathematics was almost always correct in a book, right? And so I had somehow lost my Critical because it was so beautiful, and I'm used to only seeing that kind of typesetting when an argument was totally right. I wasn't critical enough.”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  9. “Rather than the AI. And so I tend to be kind of skeptical, but also. Skeptical for another reason, and that is. Because of the nature of the large language model approach to AI doing mathematics, I recognized that the AI is trying to give me an argument that sounds like a proof rather than an argument that is a proof. The motivation is misplaced. And so I worry that this is a very dangerous source of error because it often happens in mathematics that, I mean, if I think back to when I was an undergrad, you know, here at Caltech and I was a math major eventually. And at that time, LaTeX was a pretty new thing. And I was learning LaTeX. And so I was typing up my homeworks in LaTeX. And they looked beautiful. Actually, they looked like garbage. From my current standards, I'm sure it was terrible.”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  10. “Often very surprised to hear that based on my own experience, which is quite the opposite. And so maybe my process isn't any good, although, you know, I use it for other things, like, you know, for programming things or for image generation and so on. It's amazingly powerful and helpful. But for mathematical arguments, I haven't found it helpful. And maybe I'm not interacting with it in the right way. Yet, or it could be. And so maybe I just need to improve my skill. But also, maybe I wonder like these examples that are provided by other people maybe involved quite a huge amount of interaction. And so I wonder if maybe the mathematical ideas are really coming from the person, you know, these great mathematicians who are doing it.”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  11. “If I were having such an experience with a person, I would simply refuse to talk to that person again. But okay, one has to overlook these kind of flaws. And so I tend to be a kind of skeptic about The current value of the current AI systems as far as mathematical reasoning is concerned, it seems not reliable. Okay, but I know for a fact that many that there are several prominent mathematicians who I have enormous respect for who are saying that they are using it in a way that's helpful.”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  12. “I guess I want to draw a distinction between what we have currently and what might come in future years. I've played around with it and I've tried experimenting, you know, but I haven't found it helpful at all. Basically zero, it's not. It's not helpful to me. And, you know, I've used various systems and so on, the paid models and so on. And my typical experience is interacting with AI on a mathematical question is that it gives me garbage answers that are not mathematically correct. And so I find that not helpful and also frustrating. Like if I was interacting with a person The frustrating thing is when you have to argue about whether or not that argument that they gave you is right and you point out exactly the error and the AI saying, oh, it's totally fine”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  13. “But the details of the argument have to do with kind of chess reasoning, you know, like, and my chess reading wasn't quite up to it because I would create the positions, almost all the positions are ones that I made, but this is like after many generations of being corrected by Corey because Corey would come and say, hey, this pond is hanging and it breaks your argument or, you know, this bishop can leak out of the cage or whatever. And so... And so the process was I knew kind of in terms of these ordinals what we needed to create with the position. And I would struggle to do it and create something that sort of had the features that I wanted and then I would show it to Corey and he would say, look, it doesn't.”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  14. “So I met him because he was a grad student at CUNY, where I was at the time in New York. And also, he was my son's chess coach when my son was playing chess competitively in elementary school. Then Corey was the coach. And so we knew him that way. And that was right around the time when I was getting interested in Infinite Chess. And I knew I needed a chess knowledgeable partner. And so Corey was invaluable for the paper because The proofs in this chess infinite chess are extremely finicky because you create these positions.”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  15. “And there's no promotion because there's no edge, right? Exactly. And this position that we were just talking about is a position with game value omega, which means that because it has an ordinal value, white is going to win, but black can play as though counting down from omega. What is the nature of counting down from omega? If you're black and you need to count down from omega, then you have to say a finite number.”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  16. “Right, so the rules of Infinite Chess, there's just the ordinary pieces, and they move on this infinite board, which is just a chessboard but extended in all directions, infinitely, with no edge. So there's no boundary. But the pieces move just like you'd expect. So the knights move just the same, and the rooks move on the ranks and files, and the bishops move on the same color diagonals. And just like you would expect, except they can move as far as they want, you know, if there's no intervening piece in the way.”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  17. “The interesting situation is that you present a position where there's a lot of pieces already on the board in a complicated way, and you say, what would it be like to start from this position or from that one? And we want to produce positions that have interesting features, meaning mathematically interesting features. And so I can tell you, for example, Probably a lot of people are familiar with the, say, the made-in two genre of chess problem. You know, you have a chess problem and it's white to maiden too, which means That white is going to make two moves, but the second move is going to be a checkmate. Or maybe made in three or made in five or whatever, we can have mate in N positions for any n. I mean, in infinite chess You can create a position which is not made in N for any n, but”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  18. “Yeah, absolutely. Infinite chess, fantastic. Chess ordinarily is played on this tiny, tiny board this eight by eight board, right? So when you play chess, normally it's on the eight by eight board. But we want to play infinite chess. So on the integer board, it's infinite in all four directions, but it still has the chessboard pattern. And maybe there's pieces on this board, maybe infinitely many pieces we allow. But one difference from finite ordinary chess in infinite chess, we don't Play from a standard starting position. Rather, you”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  19. “So, my approach to making mathematical progress tends to involve working with other people quite a lot rather than just working on my Own and I enjoy that aspect very much. So personally, I couldn't ever do what Wiles did. Maybe I'm missing out. Maybe if I locked myself in the bedroom and just worked on whatever, then I would help it. But I tend to think that, no, actually, like being math overflow so much and I've gotten so many ideas, so many papers have grown out of the math overflow conversations and back and forth. Someone posts a question and I post an answer on part of it and then someone else has an idea and it turns into a full solution and then we have a three-way paper coming out of that. That's happened many times. And so for me it's, I enjoy this kind of social aspect to it and it's not just the social part rather that's the nature of mathematical investigation as I see it.”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  20. “I want to work on the things that I can understand and that are simple and luckily I've found that I've been able to make contributions that other people seem to like in this way, in this style. And so I've been kind of fortunate from that point of view. I mean, my process always, though, and I've recommended this always to my students, Is just a kind of playful curiosity. So, whenever I've an idea or a topic,”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  21. “That's another difficult question. I suppose it has to do with, I mean, my mathematical style, my style as a mathematician is that I don't really like difficult mathematics. What I love is Simple, clear, easy to understand arguments that prove a surprising result. That's my favorite situation. And actually, so the question of whether it's a new result or not is somehow less important to me. And so that has to do with this question of the greats and so on, whoever does it first. Because I think, for example, if you prove a new result with a bad argument or complicated argument. That's great because you prove something new, but I still want to see the beautiful, simple, because that's what I can understand. I mean, I'm kind of naturally skeptical about any complicated argument because it might be wrong.”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  22. “I mean, of course, it's a theoretical question about the asymptotic behavior of these problems. I mean, for a problem to be in P means that there is a computable decision procedure that runs in time bounded by some polynomial. But the coefficients on that polynomial could be enormous. And the degree could be incredibly high. And so for small values of inputs, then it doesn't make sense to talk about this polynomial time feasibility with respect to, say, the range of problem inputs that we will ever give it in our lifetime or in the span of human civilization or whatever.”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  23. “It's a probabilistic way. I mean, it's probabilistic in the sense that we're solving almost all instances. Computably. This version of this that are maybe more interesting from the point of view of complexity theory and actually useful, I mean there's the whole PNP problem and so on and there's this genre of NP complete problems which are problems that are infeasible they would take exponential time to solve them in the ordinary way and they're not known to be polynomial time solvable although in these cases it's an open question whether there is a polynomial time algorithm a feasible algorithm”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  24. “That's a pretty stupid reason. Okay, but that's half of them already, just like that. Okay. And then some of them went right and they changed to a new state. And amongst those, you know, the new state, half of those ones are going left and half are going right from that place. And then most of those are changing to a new state. When there's a lot of states, it's very likely that the next state that you transition to is new. And so you get this random walk behavior if you know what that means, where half go left and half go right at each step. And there's a theorem due to polia, which is called the Polia recurrence theorem, which says, when you have a random walk, a one-dimensional random walk, then it's very likely to come back to where you started. And when that happens for us, then half of them from that place fall off on the next step.”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  25. “That was my goal. I love this. Yeah. So we thought more about it though. We hit the jackpot because we found one gigantic stupid reason that converged to 100%. I mean, in the limit. And so the stupid reason for a program not to halt is that, well, if you think about the behavior, say the head is sitting there, it's on the leftmost cell of the tape at the very beginning. It's in the start state and the head is following an instruction and the instruct state, which it is, and you're reading something on the tape, then you should write something and you should change to a new state and you should either move left and right, left or right. But half of them move left. But if you move left and you are already at the end, then the head falls off. So the conversation stops because the head fell off the tape.”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  26. “On which the machine writes zeros and ones, and the head moves back and forth according to rigid instructions. And the instructions are all of the form if the machine is in such and such a state and it's reading such and such symbol on the tape, then it should write this symbol on the tape and it should change to this new state specified and it should either move left or right as specified. So a program consists of instructions like that. If you look at a program, one of the states is the halt state, and that's when the program halts. But you can calculate how many programs Don't have any instruction that transitions to the halt state. You can easily calculate the proportion, and in the limit it goes to one over e squared, thirteen and a half percent. If you calculate the limit.”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  27. “So the asymptotic density of the programs is one. And the proof was quite fascinating because it's one of these situations where the theorem sounds really surprising, I think, to many people when I first tell it, I mean, to computability experts, then it's sort of intriguing to think that you can solve almost every instance of a halting problem. But then when they hear the proof, it's completely a letdown. Unfortunately, nobody likes the theorem after the proof. And so the proof is so simple, though. If you know what a Turing machine, how a Turing machine operates, there's this infinite paper tape.”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  28. “Certain likelihood it will have a certain behavior. And the answer turns out to be extremely interesting. Once years ago, Alexey Myaznikov asked me a question. He had this concept of a decision problem with a black hole. And what that means is it's a decision problem, which is possibly difficult in the worst case. But the difficulty was concentrated in a very tiny region called the black hole, and outside of that black hole it was very easy. And so, for example, this kind of problem is a terrible problem to use if you're basing your encryption scheme, you know, you don't want to use a black hole problem because if someone can rob the bank 95% of the time, then that's not what you want, or even any non-trivial percent of the time is too dangerous. So you don't want to use problems that are almost every case is easy.”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  29. “The main lesson of computability theory, in my view. Is that It's never the case that you can have a thorough understanding of the behavior of a program by looking at the program and that the content of what you learn from a program. I mean, in the most general case is always obtained just by running it and looking at the behavior. And the proof of that is there's a theorem called Rise's theorem, which makes that idea completely robust. But I want to just take a little detour towards another question riffing on something that you just said, namely one can ask the question, what is the behavior of a random program? So you have some formal computing language and you want to look at the collection of all programs of a certain size. Maybe there's only finitely many. And can you say something about the behavior of a randomly chosen one like with this?”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  30. “But you can still do calculus with them because you have infinitesimals if you use these non standard methods, the infinitesimal based methods to calculate. And people do that. I once organized a conference in New York and we had John Conway as a speaker at the conference and there was a question session and someone asked him, I mean, it's a bit rude question, I think, but they asked it. And the question was,”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  31. “Right, so the surreal numbers have a property that they form a non-standard model of the real field, which means that they provide a notion of infinitesimality that one can use to develop calculus on the grounds of Robinson's nonstandard theory that I had mentioned earlier. But they don't have the least upper bound properties. No non trivial set of serial numbers has at least Eborah round. And there are no convergent sequences in the serial numbers. And so for the sort of ordinary use in calculus based on limits and convergence, that method does not work in the surreal numbers at all. So that's what I mean when I say the surreal numbers are fundamentally discontinuous. They have a fundamental discontinuity going on.”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  32. “They make the surreal numbers into what's called an ordered field. So they satisfy the field axioms, which means that you have distributivity and commutativity of addition and multiplication, and also you can have reciprocals for every non-zero number you can divide by the number. So you can add and multiply and divide and subtract. And furthermore, you can take square roots, and furthermore every odd degree polynomial has a root.”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  33. “The ordinal omega itself is the firstborn number that's bigger than all those finite numbers, and minus omega is the firstborn number that's less than all those finite numbers. But also we have the number epsilon, which is the firstborn number that's strictly bigger than zero and strictly less than all the positive rational numbers. So that's going to be an infinitesimal number in that gap. And so on. On day omega plus one, we get more numbers and then omega plus two and so on. And the numbers just keep coming forever. So this is how you build the surreal number system. And then it turns out you can define the arithmetic operations of addition and multiplication in a natural way that is engaging with this recursive definition. So we have sort of recursive definitions of plus and times for the surreal numbers. And it turns out you can prove”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  34. “Going to create a lot of new surreal numbers. So every real number will be born at that stage because every real number fills a gap in the previously born rational numbers that we had just talked about. It's not all the rationals because actually the rational numbers that are born at the finite stages are just the rationals whose denominator is a power of two, it turns out. Those are called the dyadic rationals. So the real numbers are all born on day omega, but also some other numbers are born on day omega, namely”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  35. “So now we have three numbers minus one, zero, and one. And they have four gaps because there could be a number below minus one or between minus one and zero or between 0 and 1 or above 1. And so we create those four new numbers. The first number above one is called 2. The first number between 0 and 1 is called 1 half. And then on the negative side, we have minus a half and minus two and so on. So now we have, what is that seven numbers? So there's eight gaps between them. So at the next birthday, they call them the next stage will be born all the numbers between those gaps. And then between those and between those and so on. And as the days progress, we get more and more numbers. But those are just the finite birthdays because as I said, it's a transfinite process. So at day omega, that's the first infinite day.”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  36. “But now we have this number zero, and so therefore we now can define new gaps because if we put zero into the left set and have an empty right set, then we should create a new number that's bigger than zero and less than everything in the empty set. And that number is called the number one. And similarly, at that same stage, we could have put zero into the right set. And so that would be the firstborn number that's less than zero, which is called minus one”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  37. “Okay, so for example, we could start. Well, at the beginning, we don't have any numbers. We haven't created anything yet. And so, well, we could take nothing and we could divide it into two sets, the empty lower set and the empty upper set. I mean, the two empty sets. And everything in the empty set is less than everything in the empty set because that's a vacuous statement. We satisfy the conditions and we apply the number generation rule, which says we should create a new number. And this is what I call the Big Bang of numbers, the surreal genesis, when the number zero is born. Zero is the firstborn number that is bigger than everything in the empty set and less than everything in the empty set.”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  38. “Finite sequence of stages. And at every stage, we take the numbers that we have so far in all possible ways, we divide them into two sets, a lower set and an upper set, or a left set and a right set. So we divide them into these two sets so that everything in the left set is less than everything in the right set. And then at that moment, we create a new number that fits in the gap between L and R. That's it. That's all we do. So let me say it again. The rule is we proceed in stages and at any stage then in all possible ways we divide the numbers we have into two collections the left set and the right set so that everything in the left set is less than everything in the right set and we create a new number, a new surreal number that will fit in that gap.”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  39. “Yes, absolutely. I really admire his style of mathematical thinking and working in mathematics. And the surreal number sister is a good instance of this. So the way I think about the surreal numbers is what it's doing is providing us a number system that unifies all the other number systems so it extends the real numbers, well, not only it extends the integers, the natural numbers and the integers and the rational numbers and the real numbers, but also the ordinals and the infinitesimals. So they're all sitting there inside the surreal numbers. And it's this colossal system of numbers. It's not a set even. It's a proper class. It turns out because it contains all the ordinal numbers. But it's generated from nothing by a single rule. And the rule is, so we're going to generate the numbers in stages in transitions.”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  40. “In the middle of their construction, they were led to the square root of minus five or something, you know, in the construction. And they didn't have any meaning for that, but they would just do it symbolically, and eventually it would turn in, you know, because of the methods that they had, they would combine and they would cancel and so on. And all the complex parts would cancel out and they'd end up with this actual answer, you know, three plus square to 17 or whatever. And they could check it and it worked. It was a solution of the original equation. And so it must have been bewildering to them because they would start with this question purely in the real numbers, an algebraic question, and they would march on their method and proceed through the land of nonsense, you know, with these square roots of negative numbers and then end up with an answer that was real again that they could verify was correct.”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  41. “So they would have these algebraic equations that they're trying to solve, you know, and they would have the tools and methods of doing it. But then in the course of, you know, so they would have to do things to the polynomial and change the factors and so on and produce other polynomials and solve them and so on. And sometimes they could produce solutions.”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  42. “Yeah, something like that. Forcing is a way of producing a new universe, and so you could start somewhere and go to that new universe, or you could look where you are and say, well, look, I got here by doing that already in the past. So we define models of the bedrock model and ground, you know, sort of undoing the forcing. And really it was quite fruitful. And I view this as part of the sort of pluralist perspective, except the difference is that set theoretic geology is amenable to the universe view. So even though the work was inspired by this philosophical view on the multiverse view,”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  43. “But their potentialist in the sense that we could have more sets the universe could be wider and taller and so on, you know, by forcing or by extending upward. And so we want to understand the nature of this realm of set theoretic universes. And that's quite some exciting work. And so with Benedict Loeva and I, we proved some theorems on the modal logic of forcing and set theoretic potentialism under end extension. I've done a bunch of work on this topic. And also, I mounted together with Gunther Fuchs and Jonas Reitz, who was one of my own PhD students, the topic of set theoretic geology, which is studying, it's taking the metaphor of forcing, I mean, enforcing you have the ground model and the forcing extension. And when I was first working with Jonas.”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  44. “This fundamental dispute on this question. But he has a very strong and successful research program sort of trying to give legs to finding the nature of the one true set theoretic universe. And it's driving the question he's asking and the mathematical programs that he's pursuing. Whereas if you have a pluralist view as I do, then you're going to be led and attracted to questions that have to do with the interaction of different set theoretic universes, or maybe you want to understand the nature of how are the models of set theory related to their forcing extensions and so on. So this led to things that I call, say, set theoretic potentialism where you think about a set theoretic universe in a potentialist way, not in the sense of potential infinity directly because all of these universes have infinite sets inside them already.”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  45. “And the answer regrettably is apparently not because in calculus, even with that lousy, creaky foundation of infinitesimals, not even well understood that Newton and Leibniz had, they proved all the fundamental theorems of calculus. And they had all the main insights in those early days with that extremely bad foundation. And so that shows you something about the relevance of the kind of foundational views on mathematics and how important they are for mathematical developments and progress and insight. Because I view those early mathematical developments in calculus as genuinely mathematical and extremely important and insightful, even though the foundations weren't any good by contemporary perspectives. Okay, so rather, when it comes to the philosophy of set theory and the dispute between the universe view and the pluralism,”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  46. “But the foundations really were kind of completely suspect, I think, at the time. And that foundations of infinitesimal calculus really only became rigorous in the 1950s or so with the development of non-centered analysis and Robinson's work. Okay, so the point I'm trying to make is that do you need A robust, rigorous foundation of mathematics to make enduring insights in mathematics.”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  47. “First of all, I guess one should say that these different philosophical positions that you might take in the philosophy of set theory like the multiverse view or the universe view, we don't ever disagree about the mathematics. We're all agreeing on what the theorems are. It's a question of philosophical perspective on the underlying meaning or the context or really what is a philosophy of mathematics for, right? And I mean, if you look back in history, for example, like to the time of calculus with Newton and Leibniz, right? They famously developed the ideas of calculus using their concepts of infinitesimals and those foundations were roundly mocked by Bishop Barclay and so on who talked about what are these same evanescent increments and shall we not call them the ghosts of departed quantities.”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  48. “The fundamental truths are differing from one to the other, and that is the answer to the continuum hypothesis question, the fact that given any model of Seth theory, there's a forcing extension where the continued hypothesis is true and another one where it's false. You can sort of turn it on and off like a light switch. And that's the fundamental nature of the continuum hypothesis is that you can have it or you can have the negation as you like within a very closely related set theoretic world. Wherever you happen to be living, there's a closely related one where ch is true, where the continuum hypothesis is true, and one where it's false. And that itself is a kind of answer. It's not a singularist answer, a universe view answer. It's a pluralist answer. And this led me to my views on the multiverse view of set theory and”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  49. “Yeah, well, it's part of my multiverse view, I guess, which we started by, I was describing the universe view, which is the view that, look, there are facts of the matter about all of these questions and that it will turn out if you're a universe view person, which I'm not, but if you are, then you will hold that there is a right answer to the continuum hypothesis question, and there's a right answer to the large cardinal questions and so on, and that what we should be aiming to do is figure out this one true set theory. In contrast, I take the developments of set theory over the past half century or more as evidence that there isn't such a unique set theoretic reality, rather what we've been doing for decades now is producing more and more alternative set theoretic universes in which”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗

  50. “And so, how lucky we are to find the large cardinal axioms that instantiate exactly this feature of increasing consistency strength, this unending, an extremely tall hierarchy of consistency, strength of axioms, and it exactly fulfills the prediction that Girdle's theorem makes about that kind of thing. Except the axioms in the large conarchy aren't metallical self-referential statements of the form that sometimes arise in the girdle analysis, but rather they're professing existence of big infinities, these large cardinal axioms. And so it's such a welcome development. And yet, it's also known that the continuum hypothesis is independent of all of the known.”

    Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗