YouSaid · the spoken record
Joel David Hamkins
We hold 128 passages that may be Joel David Hamkins’s. We do not publish them until we can confirm who spoke. See the correction.
On the record 2025
podcast
This is everything the corpus holds for Joel David Hamkins. It is not everything they have said on the record.
Every line below is reproduced as it was said and credited to the record it came from, and links to that record wherever it can be linked. Nothing here is summarised or generated. Directory · Search · Corrections
“The property of infinity that sometimes, when you add up an element to a set, it doesn't get larger. That's what this example shows. But one can go on with Hilbert Satill, for example. I mean, maybe the next day, 20 people show up all at once. We can easily do the same trick again, just move everybody up.”
Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗
“Exactly. So there's floor zero, floor one, floor two, or room zero, one, two, three, and so on, just like the natural numbers. So Hilbert's Hotel has a room for every natural number. And it's completely full. There's a person occupying room N for every N. But meanwhile, a new guest comes up to the desk and wants a room. Can I have a room, please? And the manager says, Hang on a second, just give me a moment. And you see, when the other guests had checked in, they had to sign an agreement with the hotel that maybe there would be some changing of the rooms during the stay. And so the manager sent a message up to all the current occupants and told every person, hey, can you move up one room, please? So the person in room five would move to room six and the person in room six would move to room seven and so on and everyone moved at the same time. And of course, we never want to be placing two different guests in the same room and we won't want everyone to have their own private room. But when you move everyone up one room, then the bottom room zero becomes available.”
Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗
“A principle that Euclid appealed to in the elements, I mean, many times when he's calculating area and so on, it's a kind of basic idea that if something is just a part of another thing, then the whole is greater than the part. And so what Galileo was troubled by was this tension between what we call the Cantor-Hume principle and Euclid's principle.”
Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗
“Attitude about this situation is that those two infinities are exactly the same and that Galileo was right in those observations about the equanumerosity. And the way we would talk about it now is appeal to what I call the Cantor-Hume principle or some people just call it Hume's principle, which is the idea that if you have two collections, whether they're finite or infinite, then we want to say that those two collections have the same size. They're equinumerous if and only if there's a one-to-one correspondence between those collections. And so Galileo was observing that line segments of different lengths are equinumerous and the perfect squares are equinumerous with the whole, all of the natural numbers and to any two circles are equinumerous and so on. The tension between the candor Hume principle and what could be called Euclid's principle, which is that the whole is always greater than the part, which”
Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗
“And the midpoints are matched, and so on, so spreading out the lines as you go. And so every point on the shorter line would be associated with a unique, distinct point on the longer line in a one-to-one way. And so it seems like the two line segments have the same number of points on them because of that, even though the longer one is longer. And so it makes, again, a kind of confusion of our ideas about infinity. And also with two circles, if you just place them concentrically and draw the rays from the center, then every point on the smaller circle is associated with a corresponding point on the larger circle, you know, in a one to one way. And again, that seems to show that the smaller circle has the same number of points on it as the larger one precisely because they can be put into this one-to-one correspondence. Now, of course, the contemporary”
Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗
“Seems like on the basis of this one to one correspondence that there should be exactly the same number of squares, perfect squares as there are numbers. And yet there's all the gaps in between the perfect squares, right? And this suggests that there should be fewer perfect squares, more numbers than squares because the numbers include all the squares plus a lot more in between them, right? And Galileo was quite troubled by this observation because he took it to cause a kind of incoherence in the comparison of infinite quantities, right? Another example is if you take two lines segments of different lengths and you can imagine drawing a kind of foliation, a fan of lines that connect them so the endpoints are matched from the shorter to the longer segment.”
Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗
“In many ways, Galileo was anticipating Cantor's developments, except he couldn't quite push it all the way through and ended up throwing up his hands in confusion, in a sense. I mean, the Galileo paradox is the idea or the observation that if you think about the natural numbers, I would start with zero, but I think maybe he would start with one, the numbers 1, 2, 3, 4, and so on. And you think about which of those numbers are perfect squares. So zero squared is zero and one squared is 1 and 2 squared is 4, 3 squared is 9, 16, 25, and so on. And Galileo observed that the perfect squares can be put into a one-to-one correspondence with all of the numbers. I mean, we just did it. I associated every number with its square. And so it's...”
Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗
“Infinity at all. Galileo is an extremely prominent exception to this, though he argued against this sort of potentialist orthodoxy in the dialogue of two new science is really lovely account there that he gave.”
Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗
“I would want to start talking about infinity and telling the story much earlier than Cantor actually because, I mean, you can go all the way back to ancient Greek times when Aristotle emphasized the potential aspect of infinity as opposed to the impossibility, according to him, of achieving an actual infinity. And Archimedes' method of exhaustion where he is trying to understand the area of a region by carving it into more and more triangles, say, and sort of exhausting the area and thereby understanding the total area in terms of the sum of the areas of the pieces that he put into it. It proceeded on this kind of potential under this potentialist understanding of infinity for hundreds of years, thousands of years, almost all mathematicians were potentialists only and thought that it was incoherent to speak of an actual”
Lex Fridman Podcast31 December 2025Source ↗